STORE OPEN 10 - 5:30 daily, closed tuesdays ........... curious about exchanges? email

Surprise Card Pack -- Current Theme: LOVE/Valentine's Day!

Surprise Card Pack -- Current Theme: LOVE/Valentine's Day!

Regular price $35.00

Unit price per 

only 2 left in stock

Grab amazing cards at a fraction of the price!! Since we have a vast selection of cards, we aren't able to put cards online that we have only a few in our inventory - so you'll get an assortment of cards from our wide variety. These are completely random! These cards are final sale and cannot be switched out for other cards - sorry! Each pack is completely random - buy multiple if you're in need of a bunch of cards!

We'll release specific themed grab bags on our instagram when we have enough last of's to create enough grab bags. 

This item cannot be included in discount or promotions - If added to a sale with a discount, the order or item may be cancelled from your order - as we cannot eliminate this item on the backend - sorry! Unfortunately we cannot include stamps for grab bag cards during certain card club promotions. 

Why Common Deer?

Open tab
  • FREE GIFT WRAP.  reusable and full of "wow", available on non-sale items $25+ only! individual items can be combined to get to this minimum.  
  • FAIR WAGE SHIPPING. our fulfillment team is paid fairly and most of our materials are reused from receiving! While this method takes more time, it means reducing our impact on the environment. 
  • MORE IN STORE.  only about 10% of our inventory is listed online. The store is the full experience and we can't wait to see your face.  
  • BEST GIFTS. we were voted Best place for Unique Gifts in Vermont by our community! 
  • SHOP SMALL. rest assured knowing your picks support families and employees of the little businesses, including ours! Thanks for helping us towards a diversified economy. 
  • BUY BETTER. there are so many reasons to support domestic products, to include jobs, higher standards of production, less overseas freight costs, less waste, better quality, and much more! We encourage you to buy less, buy better. Thank you for supporting American Made. 

Need it Wrapped?

Please write which items you'd like "gift wrapped" in the notes before submitting your order! We're happy to wrap non-sale items over $25 in our reusable burlap bags.

Close (esc)


Use this popup to embed a mailing list sign up form. Alternatively use it as a simple call to action with a link to a product or a page.

Age verification

By clicking enter you are verifying that you are old enough to consume alcohol.


Shopping Cart

Your cart is currently empty.
Shop now